The beginning of
the articles talks about how a stereotypes can effect academic achievement. The
articles say that students need to become identified with school in order to
succeed. In addition, the articles talks about how students who cannot become
identified with school have a harder time succeeding in that environment. For
example, the articles states that women must come to terms with the fact that
math is a male dominated field.
Another part of the
articles talks about a stereotype threat,
which is a situational threat that
in general form, can affect the members of any group about whom a negative
stereotype exists. A stereotype threat comes from the
persons risk of confirming a negative stereotype about oneÕs group as self
characteristic. For example, if a person is constantly exposed to negative
images of his/her racial or ethnic group, this person begins to internalize the
same social and personal characteristics of these images. The article also talks about
dis-identification, which is defined to be the ability of the person (the
minority, such as women in math) to be able remove their self-identity in order
to fit into the stereotype. This allows the person to be able to fit into the
environment, but still hold on to their own values. However, it can also cause
motivational problems in the person.
Next, the articles
talks about the overprediction or
underperformance phenomenon, which occurs on test due to the way they are
written. Overprediction occurs when, the person's performance on a test, like
the SAT, achieves lower than other students with the same beginning score. The
prediction for this person does not match the actual outcomes of the test. This can happen from the way the test
is written, towards the majority.
The article also
talks about the general features of stereotype threat. First, the threat it not
tried to on specif group. Second, the threat can be turned on and off. A
teacher can help turn of the threat by reducing the relevance of the stereotype
in the classroom. Third, different groups experience different forms and degree
of stereotype threat. Fourth, you do not need to believe in the stereotype or
even the stereotype threat to experience it. Fifth, to overcome the stereotype
threat you have to get rid of the stereotype.
Finally, the
article talks about removing the stereotype. When the stereotype is removed
there is no or little difference between the performance of the majority and
the group being stereotyped. A way a teacher could remove the stereotyping from
their classroom would be to change the situation. To change the situation the teacher
need to have a optimistic teacher-student relationship, challenge the student
(to show them you believe in their abilities), and stress their intelligence.
The article "A Threat in
the Air" by Claude M. Steele covers the topic of stereotype threats and
there affects on groups of minorities such as African Americans or even just
women in general in a school setting, particularly the subjects of math and the
natural sciences. A stereotype threat
is described as "a situational threat that, in general form, can affect
the members of any group about whom a negative stereotype exists (e.g.
skateboarders, older adults, white men, gang members). Where bad stereotypes
about these groups apply, members of these groups can fear being reduced to
that stereotype. And for those who identify with the domain to which the
stereotype is relevant, this predicament can be self-threatening." A great
example is also given by psychologist James M. Jones who is quoted in this
article who wrote "When I go to the ATM machine and a woman is making a
transaction, I think about whether she will fear I may rob her. Since I have no
such intention, how do I put her at ease? Maybe I can't...and maybe she has no
such expectation. But it goes through my mind."
The article also briefly
states some statistics of how different categories of people compare to one
another academically. It discusses the gaps of achievement between Blacks and
Whites as well as between men and women. One example of a statistic given is
the fact stated that even though White women constitute 43% of the U.S.
population, they earn only 22% of the BS degrees and only 13% of the PhDs.
Thery also make up a meer 10% of the jobs in physical science, math and
engineering, where they earn only 75% of the salary that men earn.
After this, many of the tests
that were performed are explained and what concluded is stated. There are tests
that discuss: Stereotype threat of women performing in math, African Americans
on standardized tests, stereotype threat vs. genes, and so on. Most of the
tests conclude that "wise" schooling is the best practice. As for
when a stereotype threat is minimized to the lowest degree, it is easier for
any student who might be affected by this stereotype to avoid being affected by
it in a negative way, which is basically what this entire article is about.
In conclusion this article,
which for the most part I tend to agree with states what I have just said in
that "wise practices can reduce Black students' underachievement in a
real-school context and, as important, that unwise practices seem to worsen
it." Realistically this can affect any students underachievement in a
classroom and hopefully, subcoinciously increase a persons self-esteem.
Because
of societal stereotypes, individuals in certain subjects may have a hard time
identifying with that particular subject.
This inability to identify with a subject could lead to low motivation
because the individual might view their prospects in that subject as being
low. In other instances,
individuals are able to identify with their subject area but are still unable
to succeed. This occurs because of
what is known as stereotype threat.
Stereotype threat is when individuals perceive the possibility of being
judged or treated according to stereotypes. When individuals in this situation also identify with their
subject area they face also a threat to their identity.
When a
threat to an individualÕs identity occurs, the individual can often experience
disidentification.
Disidentification is when an individual no longer internalizes a subject
as a way of protecting themselves.
For example an African American student who identifies with school may
claim that they are just not a school person rather than failing in school and
conforming to stereotypes of African Americans. In many cases this leads to underperformance for many
individuals. The threat of being
stereotyped is prevalent and the individual then internalizes the stereotype.
African
Americans often experience this threat in relation to school as a whole and
school achievement. Even students
that perform exceptionally well and identify themselves as successful students,
in many cases stereotype threat occurs and they underperform.
Women
are another subgroup in this study.
Women do well in the physical sciences and math fields through middle
school. In high school they begin
to decline in performance and are much underrepresented in professional fields
involving these subjects. This is
because of stereotype threat.
Success
in school and certain subject areas is dependent upon a personÕs ability to
identify with school and its subjects.
To achieve this, a person first assesses their prospects. If they believe that they will be
successful they will identify with school or certain subjects.
In
instances where someone is in a situation where a stereotype can become
self-relevant, this is where stereotype threat can occur. For example; if a female is taking a
standardized math test. If she
performs poorly she may have to endure the stereotype that females are not good
at math. It is relevant if it
affects a personÕs self-definition.
ÒIÕm good at math.Ó This is what makes the stereotype self-relevant.
This
can lead a person to disitentify with a subject. ÒIÕm good at mathÓ turns into ÒIÕm not good at math.Ó This occurs when a person is constantly
exposed to negative stereotypes.
This can lead to inferiority anxiety and low expectations that can
eventually manifest themselves in withdrawal from school or from the
subject. A female who was once a
future engineer, now strays away from the profession. This can occur without directly being stereotyped. Just the possibility of being
stereotyped can lead to this.
The key
to stereotype threat is for the subject or for school to be self-relevant and
self-definitional. Dissociation
with school or with a certain subject will not lead to stereotype threat about
school or that subject. This,
therefore, most likely affects confident students than it does unconfident
students.